The relative quiet of recent times is in part a consequence of the final stages of dissertation writing. This process, that began nearly a year ago, came to an end on 3 February. At approximately 3pm on the aforementioned date two copies of this weighty tome were inelegantly posted through a submission letter box. After a resounding clunk from the document hitting the floor beyond the piece of work was brought to a close.
It was a strange time and one of mixed emotions. To spend such a long time with a single piece of work inevitably builds up quite a strong connection. As a result the expected sense of relief that I had envisaged was distinctly missing. Instead I had a lingering feeling that something has been taken away from me. On reflection the whole process has been characterised by feelings of enjoyment. To have the opportunity to spend such time with something you love is indeed a privilege. It has also clarified many of my thoughts and laid the foundation for work to come in the future.
Still the end must be embraced and after a few days of mourning we are back into the swing of things. More deadlines loom on the horizon and there is plenty of work to. My desk is strewn with books and previous drafts of the dissertation. They offer one last moment to consider what has taken place and realise that i have managed to write 10,000 words (10,955 to be precise) without going insane.
It can only be hoped that the remaining 4 months of the degree go equally well
Pages
Tuesday, 8 February 2011
Wednesday, 19 January 2011
following a path
Without wishing to state the obvious one of the most interesting things about the photograph is the subject that it represents. This is not to denigrate a medium that on its own is still a fascinating thing. But what really captivates our attention, and has done so for nearly 200 years, is the what we see within the confines of the frame. It is here in the subject matter of the image where the interest lies.
There are all manner of reasons why this space should prove to be so intriguing. Not least amoung these is the photographs ability to articulate something of what took place outside of the frame. For example lets consider two images with a similar composition and subject matter:
On the left we have a detail from Dennis Oppenheim's Accumulation Cut while on the right we have Wall's Crooked Path. In both images the focus of attention is the path in the centre of the frame. But our response, our mine at least, is quite different to each image. With Oppenheim i recognise that this is a channel in the ice. Also knowing what i know about ice it seems very unlikely that this channel would have formed naturally. So i conclude that this is a channel that has been cut in the ice by a human protagonist. In the full version of this piece (which can be found in an earlier post) the process by which this channel formed is made explicitly clear. But even without such information we are given the suggestion that some sort of intervention has taken place.
With Wall things are a bit different. We see the path but the location and the material with which it has been made do not immediately suggest the sort of intervention that Oppenheim enacted. While Wall could certainly have made the path himself, in a style similar to Long, it could equally be the result of everyday traffic. In short there is an element of doubt here for the viewer. Is Wall presenting us with a document here or the record of an intervention? With Wall this dilemma is enhanced by our knowledge of his working practices and use of heavily constructed imagery. In short we can never sure if Wall has constructed this image or just recorded a situation as he found it.
The purpose here is not to provide answers to this uncertainty. Rather it is to reflect on the way the photograph presents its subject and how this leads us to consider a range of processes that took place outside of the photograph. With Oppenheim we have an image that does not privilege the space of the photograph. The nature of his intervention makes for a less evocative image and it is rather the process of creating the work that we concentrate on rather than the image of it. With Wall though there is no sense that the work exists elsewhere. Instead it is all here in the confines of the frame. And while we find no resolution in this space we are given the wonderful provocation to imagine.
Saturday, 15 January 2011
C to B
On 29 October I took the train to Cosham which is a town about 50 miles from Brighton. My intention was to meet my friend at the train station and ride our bikes back to Brighton. I had done a similar trip earlier in the summer that saw me travel from London to Brighton and came to be the project called South (hopefully that publication will be made soon).
As with South I wanted to create some sort of record of this trip. But unlike South I did not want to take photographs. I had found this quite an interruption to the process of cycling and not particularly enjoyable. Also while the images were quite interesting that only felt loosely associated with the process by which they were taken. In other words they bore little evidence of bike ride that led to me being in that position at that time.
There is nothing wrong with this but I wanted to create something that actually articulated something of the process of travelling. So I decided in advance that the record of this trip would only exist in the form of a very minimal publication. I would record the time we left Cosham and the time we arrived at Brighton. In-between would be two arrows pointing right. These relate to the fact that two of us undertook this journey and that we travelled east.
The main influence on this project was Richard Long. I had been studying his work in the months leading up to the ride and was getting an idea of how he chose to represent his walks. One of the ways he does this is with text:
This text relates to a significant physical act. Long has literally walked miles but all we have of this experience is this text. What I really liked about this is that it gives the viewer plenty of space to imagine what took place. We have these brief, enigmatic pieces of text that indicate nothing off the effort, or even locations, that Long went to. We have to fill these gaps in for ourselves and imagine would took place outside of this basic info.
Long seems to recognise that trying to recreate his walk for the viewer is futile. As it takes place in reality whatever means of representation Long chooses will never come close to the experience of walking. So instead Long focuses on the act itself and this is what is at the act heart of this work: the basic process of doing.
This minimal approach to representing his work is something that occurs repeatedly in Long’s work. Another specific example that influenced my own project is his publication The North Woods. This coincided with a show Long had at the Whitechapel gallery in 1977. The book only has about 4 pages and these contain a brief amount of text and one photograph. So again Long has sought to engage the viewers imagination and ask them to recreate the work rather than present a resolved account.
I wanted to produce a similarly minimal type of publication for my own trip. I think I certainly achieved that and the information given to the viewer is pretty slender. However I think it does give enough to provide an evocative starting point for viewer. It raises questions about what happened in-between the two times and the arrows seem to indicate something but what exactly is unclear. My one problem with it is that it might be too evocative. Possibly the viewers would need a little more information to get them interested. In any case the final result can be seen here courtesy of the marevelous and highly recommended ISSU
Wednesday, 5 January 2011
a foggy notion
As a member of the 21st Century I have to except certain things. I can contact people all over the globe almost instantaneously. I can rabbit on about my thoughts and publish them for the world to see. And, if I produced the right type of photograph I could sell this for a relatively large amount of money.
But before we condemn this statement as totally naive we must remember the status of the photograph in 1968. This was not a medium that could be sold for huge sums and the art market had not conferred financial value onto the medium. When Heizer says the commodity status could be removed this is because from his point of view, and of the period in which he was working, the photograph was not a prized object.
Ironically it was work produced around this time that began to demonstrate the art value of the photograph and pave the way for the fantastic prices photographs fetch today. But this was still to come and as far as Heizer was concerned the photograph was a relatively worthless object in 1968.
All this indicates that judging the work and statements from artists has to incorporate more than just the hard facts. We must broaden our consideration to think about the socio-economic context they worked in; contemporary theories in art and the nature of the art market. All these things shape an artists production and if we neglect to explore the influence such things have then we risk being naive ourselves.
Each of these things is astounding in its own right and equally we would have struggled to do any of them in 1968. With regards to the first two pronouncements this comes as little surprise. But with the final one this may not be so obvious. Nonetheless though it is fairly accurate to say that in 1968 art photography was not a widely recognised practice and proponents of this art form stood to gain little financial reward from it.
In a round about way this brings us to the topic of todays post: photography in Land Art.
![]() |
| Isolated Mass, Circumflex 1968 |
In 1968 Michael Heizer travelled in to the Nevada Desert and cut a curvaceous channel in the ground. That we know anything about this at all is down to the photographs taken of this intervention into nature. From the photograph we get the rudimentary idea of Heizer's work and the basic form it took.
Isolated Mass, Circumflex is one example of the type of work that would come to be grouped under the banner of Land or Environmental Art. Protagonists such as Oppenheim, Haacke, Smithson rejected the traditional role of the artist and sought to explore new places and new materials. There was a sense that art was being liberated from its traditional confines of the studio and gallery. Now it could exist anywhere and be made of anything. Heizer himself had high hopes for such work and elaborated on its potential in idealistic terms:
'one aspect of earth orientation is that works circumvent the galleries and the artist has no sense of the commercial or the utilitarian...One of the implications of Earth Art might be to remove completely the commodity status of a work of art'For contemporary audiences such a statement seems tremendously naive. The complete removal of arts commodity status has far from been acheived and all manner of work still sells for huge sums. Land Art is no exception. The photographs taken of these interventions act to commodify what Heizer felt could be un-commodifiable. They take what is site-specific and temporary and give it material form. What's more it is a form that can be easily reporduced and circulated to a wide audience. So while the initial intervention is hard to commodify the resulting documents more than make up for this.
But before we condemn this statement as totally naive we must remember the status of the photograph in 1968. This was not a medium that could be sold for huge sums and the art market had not conferred financial value onto the medium. When Heizer says the commodity status could be removed this is because from his point of view, and of the period in which he was working, the photograph was not a prized object.
Ironically it was work produced around this time that began to demonstrate the art value of the photograph and pave the way for the fantastic prices photographs fetch today. But this was still to come and as far as Heizer was concerned the photograph was a relatively worthless object in 1968.
All this indicates that judging the work and statements from artists has to incorporate more than just the hard facts. We must broaden our consideration to think about the socio-economic context they worked in; contemporary theories in art and the nature of the art market. All these things shape an artists production and if we neglect to explore the influence such things have then we risk being naive ourselves.
Thursday, 30 December 2010
i hope i learn something from this
Continuing on with practical matters I have been giving some thought to how art work is experienced. What sort of response do we get from art and what does it leave us with? There is obviously not going to be a single answer to this question. Our reaction to a piece of art can range from anger to joy to deep reflection. But is one type of response that I am particularly interested in and that is how art can increase our knowledge.
I was led down this train of thought after reading some of Kirsi Peltomaki book called Situation Aesthetics that deals with the work of Michael Asher. Asher is best known for his interventions into institutional spaces, typically the gallery or museum, that disturb our perception of that space. Early pieces such as the one pictured (all Ashers works have no title) involved Asher removing the dividing wall that seperated the gallery from the office space at the Clare Copley Gallery. This simple gesture directs us to the administrative and commercial aspects of the gallery that are normally hidden from sight.
This was a piece that i was familiar with and could grasp its significance. Many galleries contrive to appear as just places to show art and the commercial side of things are firmly placed behind closed doors. By removing the divide, both literally and metaphorically, we encounter an often unseen side of the institution.
But this was as far as I had ever got and gave little thought to what was actually taking place for the viewer. By visiting this space our knowledge of that institution is being increased. To use Peltomaki's term Asher's intervention is 'knowledge producing'. As an artist Asher does not just evoke an emotional response but actually contributes to what we know about art and how it functions in society. The nature of this knowledge is also important. It is not something that is given to the viewer like a report or history book. Instead it is 'produced' by the viewer after considering the work. In this sense we are given the chance to engage with work and discover it for ourselves. As a result we are left with a tangible insight, that transcends aesthetic of physical constraints, which we have arrived at after a reciprocal dialogue.
Part of the reason I never really thought of this is that I can never experience the work first hand. The production of knowledge relies on such an encounter in situ and no amount of photographs can ever compensate if this is lacking. Asher's initial intervention then is intrinsically site specific: we need to experience it first hand to fully engage with it. However as the work articulates issues that transcend that physical space we do not feel completely detached from it. So even if we get a second hand account the significance of Asher's achievements do not go unnoticed.
![]() |
| Clare Copley Gallery 1974 |
This was a piece that i was familiar with and could grasp its significance. Many galleries contrive to appear as just places to show art and the commercial side of things are firmly placed behind closed doors. By removing the divide, both literally and metaphorically, we encounter an often unseen side of the institution.
But this was as far as I had ever got and gave little thought to what was actually taking place for the viewer. By visiting this space our knowledge of that institution is being increased. To use Peltomaki's term Asher's intervention is 'knowledge producing'. As an artist Asher does not just evoke an emotional response but actually contributes to what we know about art and how it functions in society. The nature of this knowledge is also important. It is not something that is given to the viewer like a report or history book. Instead it is 'produced' by the viewer after considering the work. In this sense we are given the chance to engage with work and discover it for ourselves. As a result we are left with a tangible insight, that transcends aesthetic of physical constraints, which we have arrived at after a reciprocal dialogue.
Part of the reason I never really thought of this is that I can never experience the work first hand. The production of knowledge relies on such an encounter in situ and no amount of photographs can ever compensate if this is lacking. Asher's initial intervention then is intrinsically site specific: we need to experience it first hand to fully engage with it. However as the work articulates issues that transcend that physical space we do not feel completely detached from it. So even if we get a second hand account the significance of Asher's achievements do not go unnoticed.
Wednesday, 29 December 2010
between thought and expression
The denouement of my degree is fast approaching and January is set up to be an invigorating if necessarily anti-social month. While the majority of this period will be spent giving my dissertation some semblance of cohesion there is also the small matter of my final project to consider. Fortunately I have been able to do just that over the last few weeks and consequentially I have some direction but also numerous obstacles.
To set the scene it would be worth explaining the basic premise of my project. In essence it is quite simple: show a series of films at a number of outdoor locations. The films will be simple, straight on shots of the location in which they will be shown. They will be projected onto a screen at night so when seen the viewer will simultaneously experience the location in both day and night. Complicated? Possibly but hopefully this mock up will help clarify things a bit:
There are a dizzying amount of conceptual and practical problems to sort out with the project and these will undoubtedly crop up in future posts. But one of the immediate issues that got me thinking is how will this project translate into a gallery space. The question is mainly a contrivance of my course as I need to physically submit something come late May. But there is a bigger question here of how does the documentation of something that is in many ways site specific alter the piece?
In this case the change is going to be significant. When viewed initially the projections will very much be directly related to the place they are shown. I aiming for a sort of gently interruption to our usual perception of a place. This achieved I hope it will allow for a reconsideration of our environment. At the heart of this project then is our interaction with the world around us and reflecting on this space. The artifice I insert into this space is a catalyst to provoke this process and the work itself is not the focus of attention. However once documented the physical site is no longer present. The project becomes seen through an intermediary and this fundamentally alters the premise of the work.
Or so I thought. After taking a walk and thinking these things through I realised that the documentation could actually facilitate the same sort of reflective response I am after. However the viewer would no longer be reflecting on a physical place but the general process of representation. For example if I produced a film there would be a film within a film. This can't help but draw attention to the tools by which we record the world around us.
When this first came to me I thought it felt a bit dry. I was concerned that I mind end up simply discussing the merits of a particular medium and the process of documentation. I want my work to have a broader reach than this and not simply address what I felt were narrow issues. But after a bit more thought I realised within the process of representation there exists the possibility to make a much broader statement. When thinking about this I had David Hockneys Joiners in my mind.
What is initially so remarkable about Hockney's work is the process he has used to record his subject. We recognise the use of photography but the feeling of dislocation we get is not something would be usually experience when viewing an image. In short this is not something we are used to seeing and the photograph seems unfamiliar in this role.
That Hockney is able to make something as ubiquitous as the photograph appear strange is quite an achievement. Our expectations of the medium have been subverted and we are left to reflect on this unusual style of presentation. That are our assumptions are confounded allows us to reflect on how we would usually engage with a photograph. In newspapers, magazines and adverts the image us usually presented as a cohesive entity and is employed to convey a clear message. But Hockney reveals that this is not a characteristic inherent in the medium and the photograph can be put to quite different uses.
So what may initially appear as a comment on representation acts as the starting point for how the photograph operates in society. Such a point seems particularly relevant in a media saturated world and increased awareness of how such media are constructed is surely of benefit.
For my own work then I hope the way it is presented directs you away from the rather dry technical issues of presentation and towards a broader consideration of the media and how it is used.
There are a dizzying amount of conceptual and practical problems to sort out with the project and these will undoubtedly crop up in future posts. But one of the immediate issues that got me thinking is how will this project translate into a gallery space. The question is mainly a contrivance of my course as I need to physically submit something come late May. But there is a bigger question here of how does the documentation of something that is in many ways site specific alter the piece?
In this case the change is going to be significant. When viewed initially the projections will very much be directly related to the place they are shown. I aiming for a sort of gently interruption to our usual perception of a place. This achieved I hope it will allow for a reconsideration of our environment. At the heart of this project then is our interaction with the world around us and reflecting on this space. The artifice I insert into this space is a catalyst to provoke this process and the work itself is not the focus of attention. However once documented the physical site is no longer present. The project becomes seen through an intermediary and this fundamentally alters the premise of the work.
Or so I thought. After taking a walk and thinking these things through I realised that the documentation could actually facilitate the same sort of reflective response I am after. However the viewer would no longer be reflecting on a physical place but the general process of representation. For example if I produced a film there would be a film within a film. This can't help but draw attention to the tools by which we record the world around us.
When this first came to me I thought it felt a bit dry. I was concerned that I mind end up simply discussing the merits of a particular medium and the process of documentation. I want my work to have a broader reach than this and not simply address what I felt were narrow issues. But after a bit more thought I realised within the process of representation there exists the possibility to make a much broader statement. When thinking about this I had David Hockneys Joiners in my mind.
What is initially so remarkable about Hockney's work is the process he has used to record his subject. We recognise the use of photography but the feeling of dislocation we get is not something would be usually experience when viewing an image. In short this is not something we are used to seeing and the photograph seems unfamiliar in this role.
That Hockney is able to make something as ubiquitous as the photograph appear strange is quite an achievement. Our expectations of the medium have been subverted and we are left to reflect on this unusual style of presentation. That are our assumptions are confounded allows us to reflect on how we would usually engage with a photograph. In newspapers, magazines and adverts the image us usually presented as a cohesive entity and is employed to convey a clear message. But Hockney reveals that this is not a characteristic inherent in the medium and the photograph can be put to quite different uses.
So what may initially appear as a comment on representation acts as the starting point for how the photograph operates in society. Such a point seems particularly relevant in a media saturated world and increased awareness of how such media are constructed is surely of benefit.
For my own work then I hope the way it is presented directs you away from the rather dry technical issues of presentation and towards a broader consideration of the media and how it is used.
Tuesday, 14 December 2010
Metaphysics
Amidst the ongoing dissertation writing process i am consciously making an effort to distract myself. This may seem a little odd but it is a useful tactic in the fight to remain productive. I do this because i know that i will, at some point, get distracted. Armed with such knowledge i will occasionally give myself a small break which allows some respite from the rigors of writing.
Such breaks could involve a walk or household chore but today i decided to take a look at an anthology of conceptual art. One of the pieces that i came across was Metaphysics by Jaroslaw Kozlowski:
Such breaks could involve a walk or household chore but today i decided to take a look at an anthology of conceptual art. One of the pieces that i came across was Metaphysics by Jaroslaw Kozlowski:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








